Licht Armor VS Holy Mail

In my younger paladin days when fighting Blitz in MQ I was horriblly outmatched, but I was helped by a random paladin senpai that was dressed in white armor that looked so simple yet had a presence of an S class adventurer around it like you'd see in anime and manga, she one shotted blitz with a single holy thrust even though I was struggling so hard fighting him. I forgot her name but I have not forgotten the equips she told me she was using: Crysta hammer and Holy mail. This event is what sparked an addiction to experimenting with equips to such an extent that the only reason I have not amassed billions of spins is because I spend them all of xtal crysta, equips and al crysta to spend stuff on. From these experiments I've found many amazing results that seem almost too OP for paladin standards. But recently I've obtained a licht armor (strengthened 3) after a long while of grinding and I've now come to a question:

Which is better? Holy Mail or Licht armor?

Licht Armor (Strengthened 3) [Armor]
DEF: 25
DEF&MDEF up based on Lv Melee&Magic R +14%, Delay -1.2 sec. MaxHP+10% Chance to lower skill delay by defense

VS

Holy Mail [Armor]
DEF: 25
MaxHP+15%, Magic R +20% Hate rise +25%, Melee+15% to Dark Light R +10%, Dark R +10%

At first you'd look at the licht armor and say its better but when using it the holy mail is way better at tanking magic attacks, has a higher HP bonus and gives more DMG via holy thrust. But licht has better skill delay and is better at tanking melee attacks but doesn't fall short on tanking magic attacks.