Dragon's Claw III VS Black Rose Chakram?

Dragon's Claw III [Claws] 📷
ATK: 300
Autoskill+8% Evasion+14% MaxHP+25% Crt damage +14%, HP absorb chance Magic R -15%, Dark element
Melee to Light +20% Magic R -15% Autoskill +8% Critical damage +14% Evasion +14% MaxHP +25% Autoskill

Black Rose Chakram [Claws]
ATK: 300
ATK+10%, MaxHP+10%, Critical up Bleed rate +3%, Bleed damage +20% Magic R -15% HP recovery chance by attack.
ATK +10% Critical rate +10 Critical damage +10% MaxHP +10% Bleed +3% Bleed dmg +20% Magic R -15% Autoskill

Atk stat dclaw 3 same as brc (q0 at 300 q15 at 315 q30 at 330).

Dclaw3 power score = 1,5x20 + 1x0 + 0,75x14 = 40,5 (on light mob)
Brc score = 1,5x0 + 1x10 + 0,75x10 = 17,5

For single item performance. On Light mob dclaw3 win by 23points to brc. On other than light brc win bout 7,5 points to dclaw3.

Brc bleed on non bk kinda very low n it proc bad
Quoted test
"
Black rose chakram (claw type). Its autoheal seem hv similar formula as dclaw. However ofc it proc lower rate than dclaw. It gv bleed time bout 4-5sec but only 380 dmg tou t boss on atk state. So bleed kinda very low dmg n very short duration.

Hope thats help. Hv fun...
"
Read more: irunaonline.boards.net/thread/27982/iruna-online-info-website?page=17#ixzz65NieIEIB

Brc nice n coheren with bk skill

Beast Slash 1
Slash an enemy like a beast. Different effects between Swords and Claws. Chance to inflict Bleed.
Lv 120 Beast Slash 1 App. Beast Knight
Lv 140 Beast Slash 2 Quest - The Beast Slash
Lv 260 Beast Slash 3 Item - Claw Sword 3

For coherence autoskill build kinda monk then dclaw3 is better coz 8%autoskill help proc better on other (wyn veleno showy hp absorb etc autoskill)

For light mob n coherence with other skill then dclaw3 is a better choice over brc regardless of monk or bk

Hope thats help..

PN. For solely spina purpose then knuckle shield s hv t highest claw price 2b-2,5b. So more profit harvested from claw slotter