Success Rate Guide

{Smithing}
Melee to Fire

[12.0] Grasegone◇Blue Rain◇Blue Rain
[10.4] Freesia Weapon II◇Blue Rain◇Blue Rain
[10.0] Water Element Weapon◇Blue Rain◇Blue Rain
[9.0] Grasegone◇Blue Rain
[8.4] Freesia Weapon II◇Eisen◇Eisen
[8.0] Grasegone◇Eisen
[8.0] Water Element Weapon◇Eisen◇Eisen
[7.4] Freesia Weapon II◇Blue Rain
[7.2] Grasegone◇Fire Enhancer III
[7.0] Water Element Weapon◇Blue Rain
[6.4] Freesia Weapon II◇Eisen
[6.0] Water Element Weapon◇Eisen
[5.6] Freesia Weapon II◇Fire Enhancer III
[5.2] Water Element Weapon◇Fire Enhancer III

[4.0] Any Body◇Eisen◇Eisen
[2.0] Any Body◇Eisen
[1.2] Any Body◇Fire Enhancer III

[8.8] Ice Cape◇Captain Beelzem◇Captain Beelzem
[8.0] Libersona◇Captain Beelzem◇Captain Beelzem
[5.8] Ice Cape◇Captain Beelzem
[5.0] Libersona◇Captain Beelzem
[4.8] Ice Cape◇Eisen
[4.0] Libersona◇Eisen
[4.0] Ice Cape◇Fire Enhancer III
[3.2] Libersona◇Fire Enhancer III

[4.0] Production Book◇Eisen◇Eisen
[2.0] Production Book◇Eisen

[3.0] Ice of Death
[2.0] Spikeleon
[2.0] Rua II
[1.0] Rua
[0.6] Sauro II
[0.6] Sauro III

[16.0] 16x □Smithing success +1%
...
[1.0] 1x □Smithing success +1%
[0.2] 1x □Melee to Fire +1%

[18.12] 453 STR (max at level 395)
[10.0] Alch skill: Production Workshop
[10.0] Alch skill: Craft Technique IV
[5.0] Production Ticket
[4.0] Frozen Meat
[2.0] Water Drink
[2.0] Burning Clapper
[0.2] Pet skill: All Around
[?] Ench skill: Origin & Mana Conversion
[?] Fortune Colour Red

{Tailoring}
Melee to Wind

[11.6] Fleurselman (up)◇Aurumteus◇Aurumteus
[10.6] Fleurselman◇Aurumteus◇Aurumteus
[10.4] River Stone Moss Bow◇Aurumteus◇Aurumteus
[8.6] Fleurselman◇Aurumteus
[8.4] River Stone Moss Bow◇Aurumteus
[8.0] Earth Element Weapon◇Aurumteus◇Aurumteus
[7.8] Fleurselman◇Wind Enhancer III
[7.6] River Stone Moss Bow◇Wind Enhancer III
[6.0] Earth Element Weapon◇Aurumteus
[5.2] Earth Element Weapon◇Wind Enhancer III

[4.0] Any Body◇Aurumteus◇Aurumteus
[2.0] Any Body◇Aurumteus
[1.2] Any Body◇Wind Enhancer III

[9.4] Failwind (up)◇Pursuer◇Pursuer
[9.0] Failwind◇Pursuer◇Pursuer
[8.0] Libersona◇Pursuer◇Pursuer
[6.0] Failwind◇Pursuer
[5.0] Libersona◇Pursuer
[5.0] Failwind◇Aurumteus
[4.2] Failwind◇Wind Enhancer III
[4.0] Libersona◇Aurumteus
[3.2] Libersona◇Wind Enhancer III

[4.0] Production Book◇Aurumteus◇Aurumteus
[2.0] Production Book◇Aurumteus

[3.0] Stone of Trial
[2.0] Spikeleon
[2.0] Anis
[0.6] Sauro II
[0.6] Sauro III

[16.0] 16x □Tailoring success +1%
...
[1.0] 1x □Tailoring success +1%
[0.2] 1x □Melee to Wind +1%

[18.12] 453 AGI (max at level 395)
[10.0] Alch skill: Production Workshop
[10.0] Alch skill: Craft Technique IV
[5.0] Production Ticket
[3.0] Storm Breath
[2.0] Earth Drink
[0.2] Pet skill: All Around
[?] Ench skill: Origin & Mana Conversion
[?] Fortune Colour Green

{Carpentry}
Melee to Earth

[10.0] Hunter's Swordbow (up)◇Vatendeth◇Vatendeth
[9.0] Purgatory Bow◇Vatendeth◇Vatendeth
[8.0] Hunter's Swordbow (up)◇Vatendeth
[8.0] Fire Element Weapon◇Vatendeth◇Vatendeth
[7.2] Hunter's Swordbow (up)◇Earth Enhancer III
[7.0] Purgatory Bow◇Vatendeth
[6.0] Fire Element Weapon◇Vatendeth
[6.2] Purgatory Bow◇Earth Enhancer III
[5.2] Fire Element Weapon◇Earth Enhancer III

[10.0] Lava Mail◇Foxxus◇Foxxus
[6.8] Lava Mail◇Foxxus
[6.4] Any Body◇Foxxus◇Foxxus
[5.6] Lava Mail◇Vatendeth
[4.8] Lava Mail◇Earth Enhancer III
[3.2] Any Body◇Foxxus
[2.0] Any Body◇Vatendeth
[1.2] Any Body◇Earth Enhancer III

[8.2] Hibiscus (up2)◇Sakimori no Ryu◇Sakimori no Ryu
[8.0] Libersona◇Sakimori no Ryu◇Sakimori no Ryu
[6.4] Lava Guard◇Sakimori no Ryu◇Sakimori no Ryu
[5.2] Hibiscus (up2)◇Sakimori no Ryu
[5.0] Libersona◇Sakimori no Ryu
[4.0] Libersona◇Vatendeth
[3.8] Lava Guard◇Sakimori no Ryu
[3.2] Libersona◇Earth Enhancer III
[2.8] Lava Guard◇Vatendeth
[2.0] Lava Guard◇Earth Enhancer III

[4.0] Production Book◇Sakimori no Ryu◇Sakimori no Ryu
[2.0] Production Book◇Sakimori no Ryu

[3.0] Flame of Calling
[2.0] Spikeleon
[2.0] Theru II
[1.0] Theru
[0.6] Sauro II
[0.6] Sauro III

[16.0] 16x □Carpentry success +1%
...
[1.0] 1x □Carpentry success +1%
[0.2] 1x □Melee to Earth +1%

[18.12] 453 VIT (max at level 395)
[10.0] Alch skill: Production Workshop
[10.0] Alch skill: Craft Technique IV
[5.0] Production Ticket
[2.0] Fire Drink
[0.2] Pet skill: All Around
[?] Ench skill: Origin & Mana Conversion
[?] Fortune Colour Yellow

{Chasing}
Melee to Light

*◇Halios = ◇Ginami
Uroboros◇Ginami◇Ginami is also an 8.4 weapon for Alchemy
Any Body◇Ginami◇Ginami is also a 4.0 body for Alchemy
You can use a phrase shortcut to swap to your success set after an autoskill triggers

[10.4] Uroboros II◇The Shadow of the Wandering◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[10.0] Dark Element Weapon◇The Shadow of the Wandering◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[8.4] Uroboros II◇Halios◇Halios
[8.0] Dark Element Weapon◇Halios◇Halios
[7.4] Uroboros II◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[7.0] Dark Element Weapon◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[6.4] Uroboros II◇Halios
[6.0] Dark Element Weapon◇Halios
[5.6] Uroboros II◇Light Enhancer III
[5.2] Dark Element Weapon◇Light Enhancer III

[6.0] Any Body◇The Shadow of the Wandering◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[4.0] Any Body◇Halios◇Halios
[3.0] Any Body◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[2.0] Any Body◇Halios
[1.2] Any Body◇Light Enhancer III

[9.4] Dark Helm (up)◇Nero◇Nero
[8.0] Nightcap◇Nero◇Nero
[6.4] Dark Helm (up)◇Nero
[6.0] Any Additional◇Nero◇Nero
[5.0] Nightcap◇Nero
[4.0] Nightcap◇Halios
[3.2] Nightcap◇Light Enhancer III
[3.0] Any Additional◇Nero
[1.2] Any Additional◇Light Enhancer III

[6.0] Production Book◇The Shadow of the Wandering◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[4.0] Production Book◇Ginami◇Ginami
[3.0] Production Book◇The Shadow of the Wandering
[2.0] Production Book◇Ginami

[3.0] The Shadow of the Wandering
[2.0] Spikeleon
[2.0] Enina II
[1.0] Biflog
[0.6] Sauro II
[0.6] Sauro III

[16.0] 16x □Chasing success +1%
...
[1.0] 1x □Chasing success +1%
[0.2] 1x □Melee to Light +1%

[18.12] 453 DEX (max at level 395)
[10.0] Alch skill: Production Workshop
[10.0] Alch skill: Craft Technique IV
[5.0] Production Ticket
[4.0] Fallen God Sword 15sec autoskill (not tested)
[4.0] Ghost Ring 15sec autoskill (not tested)
[2.0] Dark Drink
[0.2] Pet skill: All Around 
[?] Fortune Colour White

{Alchemy}
Melee to Dark

*Eclaire IV = Mistia
*Stavros = Excalibur+
*Silver Mail (noup) = Holy Mail
*◇Ninigi = ◇Argyros = ◇Ginami

[12.0] Eclaire IV◇Flash of Day◇Flash of Day
[11.0] Stavros◇Flash of Day◇Flash of Day
[10.0] Eclaire IV◇Ninigi◇Ninigi
[9.0] Stavros◇Ninigi◇Ninigi
[9.0] Eclaire IV◇Flash of Day
[8.0] Light Element Weapon◇Ninigi◇Ninigi
[8.0] Eclaire IV◇Ninigi
[7.2] Eclaire IV◇Dark Enhancer III
[7.0] Stavros◇Ninigi
[6.2] Stavros◇Dark Enhancer III
[6.0] Light Element Weapon◇Ninigi
[5.2] Light Element Weapon◇Dark Enhancer III

[9.6] Silver Mail (up)◇Flash of Day◇Flash of Day
[7.6] Silver Mail (up)◇Ninigi◇Ninigi
[6.6] Silver Mail (up) ◇Flash of Day
[5.6] Silver Mail (up) ◇Ninigi
[4.8] Silver Mail (up) ◇Dark Enhancer III
[4.0] Any Body◇Ninigi◇Ninigi
[2.0] Any Body◇Ninigi
[1.2] Any Body◇Dark Enhancer III

[8.5] White Maid Headdress◇Niapa◇Niapa
[7.6] Pratzen (up2)◇Niapa◇Niapa
[7.2] Black Scarf◇Niapa◇Niapa
[6.0] Any Additional◇Niapa◇Niapa
[5.5] White Maid Headdress◇Niapa
[4.2] Black Scarf◇Niapa
[3.2] White Maid Headdress◇Dark Enhancer III
[3.0] Any Additional◇Niapa
[2.4] Black Scarf◇Dark Enhancer III
[2.0] Any Additional◇Ninigi
[1.2] Any Additional◇Dark Enhancer III

[6.0] Production Book◇Flash of Day◇Flash of Day
[4.0] Production Book◇Ginami◇Ginami
[3.0] Production Book◇Flash of Day
[2.0] Production Book◇Ginami

[3.0] Flash of Day
[2.0] Spikeleon
[1.0] Lunange
[0.6] Sauro II
[0.6] Sauro III

[16.0] 16x □Alchemy success +1%
...
[1.0] 1x □Alchemy success +1%
[0.2] 1x □Melee to Dark +1%

[18.12] 453 INT (max at level 395)
[10.0] Alch skill: Production Workshop
[10.0] Alch skill: Craft Technique IV
[5.0] Production Ticket
[2.0] Flint
[2.0] Burning Clapper (may have the same buff name as Flint?)
[2.0] Light Drink
[0.2] Pet skill: All Around
[?] Sin skill: Darkness (not tested. self buff or party buff?)
[?] Paladin skill: Gloria (not tested, party buff)
[?] Fortune Colour Black

{"But how do I make production relic?"}

	Old Memory Fragment	Old Fire Fragment	Old Water Fragment	Old Wind Fragment	Old Earth Fragment	Old Light Fragment	Old Dark Fragment
Quartz Energy Uradoom ATK•MATK+5 ATK•MATK+1%	MP Cost -1% EXP gain +1% Magic+100	STR+1 ATK+1 Melee+100	INT+1 MaxMP+20 Heal reward +1%	AGI+1 MATK+1 Hate rise -1%	VIT+1 MaxHP+100 Melee pierce +1%	DEX+1 Cast time -1% Heal recovery +1%	CRT+1 Hate rise +1% Magic pierce +1%
Pleasure Cry Debby MATK+2% Rate Cut+2%	MaxHP+100 MaxMP+20 Drop rate +1%	STR+1 Melee+1% to Fire Fire magic +1%	INT+1 Melee+1% to Water Water magic +1%	AGI+1 Melee+1% to Wind Wind magic +1%	VIT+1 Melee+1% to Earth Earth magic +1%	DEX+1 Melee+1% to Light Light magic +1%	CRT+1 Melee+1% to Dark Dark magic +1%
Nature Aid Gigant Colon MaxHP+5% Evasion-10%	ATK+1 MATK+1 EXP gain +1%	STR+1 Smith success +1% Burn damage +1%	INT+1 Cook success +1% MP Cost -1%	AGI+1 Sew success +1% Bleed damage +1%	VIT+1 Carpentry suc. +1% Melee+1%	DEX+1 Chasing success +1% Magic+1%	CRT+1 Alchemy success +1% Poison dmg +1%
Steel Skin Oswald ATK+2% Absolute Evasion +3%	ATK+1 Magic+100 Magic+1%	STR+1 Melee+100 Melee+1%	INT+1 Heal recovery +1% Heal reward +1%	AGI+1 MaxHP+100 MaxMP+20	VIT+1 Hate rise +1% Melee pierce +1%	DEX+1 MP cost -1% Cast time -1%	CRT+1 Hate rise -1% Magic Pierce +1%
Amethyst Knowledge Angenger Crit dmg+5%, ATK -2%	EXP gain +1% Magic+1% Drop rate +1%	STR+1 Fire magic +1% Smith success +1%	INT+1 Water magic +1% Cook success +1%	AGI+1 Wind magic +1% Sew success +1%	VIT+1 Earth magic +1% Carpentry suc. +1%	DEX+1 Light magic +1% Chasing success +1%	CRT+1 Dark magic +1% Alchemy success +1%
Nagera Rusti Roy ATK +2%, DEX+2	ATK+1 MaxHP+1% Bleed damage +1%	STR+1 Hate rise +1% Melee+1%	INT+1 Hate rise -1% Magic +1%	AGI+1 Melee+1% to Wind Melee pierce +1%	VIT+1 Earth magic +1% Magic pierce +1%	DEX+1 Heal recovery +1% Light magic +1%	CRT+1 Poison dmg +1% Dark magic +1%
Silver Reijin Giorgio MeleeR•MagicR +2%	ATK+1 MaxHP+100 MaxHP+1%	STR+1 MaxMP+20 Hate rise +1%	INT+1 Melee+100 Magic+100	AGI+1 Melee+1% to Wind Wind magic +1%	VIT+1 Melee+1% to Earth Earth magic +1%	DEX+1 Bleed damage +1% MaxMP+1%	CRT+1 EXP gain +1% Melee pierce +1%
Plagmain Nejua KO-1sec Damage cut in stun +5%	ATK+1 Cast time -1% MP cost -1%	STR+1 Burn damage +1% Bleed damage +1%	INT+1 Melee+1% to Water Water Magic +1%	AGI+1 Sew success +1% Magic+1%	VIT+1 Carpentry suc. +1% Melee+1%	DEX+1 Heal Recovery +1% Drop rate +1%	CRT+1 Poison dmg +1% EXP gain +1%
Stora Cave Altern MaxMP +3% VIT+3	ATK+1 MaxMP+1% Heal recovery +1%	STR+1 Fire magic +1% Hate rise +1%	INT+1 MATK+1 Hate rise -1%	AGI+1 MP cost -1% Wind magic +1%	VIT+1 Melee+100 Smith success +1%	DEX+1 Light magic +1% Heal reward +1%	CRT+1 Magic pierce +1% Alchemy success +1%
Canal Levi Trashiddoh Paralysis -1sec MATK +2%	ATK+1 MaxMP+1% MATK+1	STR+1 Bleed damage +1% Melee+1% to Fire	INT+1 Water magic +1% Melee+1% to Water	AGI+1 Heal recovery +1% Alchemy success +1%	VIT+1 Earth magic +1% Magic+100	DEX+1 Cast time -1% Magic+1%	CRT+1 Posion damage +1% Magic pierce +1%
Desert Grass Mish Poison dmg +3% Crit dmg +3%	ATK+1 Melee pierce +1% Magic +1%	STR+1 Burn damage +1% Melee+100	INT+1 Water magic +1% Heal reward +1%	AGI+1 Wind magic +1% Heal recovery +1%	VIT+1 Hate rise +1% MaxHP +1%	DEX+1 Exp gain +1% MP cost -1%	CRT+1 Dark magic +1% Poison dmg +1%
Caelest Callecra Melee Pierce +1% VIT+2	ATK+1 MaxHP +1% Hate rise +1%	STR+1 Melee to Fire +1% Melee+1%	INT+1 Melee to Fire +1% Water magic +1%	AGI+1 Melee to Wind +1% Magic+100	VIT+1 Melee to Earth +1% Exp gain +1%	DEX+1 Cast time -1% Drop rate +1%	CRT+1 Smith success +1% Cook success +1%
Lavaberg Blaiard Magic Pierce +1% Cast Defense +5%	ATK+1 Melee pierce +1% Magic pierce +1%	STR+1 Melee to Fire +1% Fire magic +1%	INT+1 Melee to water +1% Magic+100	AGI+1 EXP gain +1% Drop rate +1%	VIT+1 Melee to earth +1% Earth magic +1%	DEX+1 Smith success +1% Alchemy success +1%	CRT+1 Burn damage +1% Bleed damage +1%
O'Apelago Cordal Melee to Light +1% AGI+3	ATK+1 Magic+100 Magic +1%	STR+1 Hate rise +1% Fire magic +1%	INT+1 Cast time -1% Water magic +1%	AGI+1 MP cost -1% Wind magic +1%	VIT+1 Drop rate +1% Earth magic +1%	DEX+1 Melee to Light +1% Light magic +1%	CRT+1 Smith success +1% Alchemy success +1%
Alt Edge Vapawr STR•INT+2 Paralysis -1sec	ATK+1 Melee +1% Magic +1%	STR+1 Melee to Fire +1% Hate rise +1%	INT+1 Melee to Water +1% Water magic +1%	AGI+1 Melee to Wind +1% Wind magic +1%	VIT+1 Melee+100 Melee pierce +1%	DEX+1 Magic+100 Chasing success +1%	CRT+1 Bleed damage +1% Drop rate +1%
Puffy Ori Elana MeleeR +2% DEX+3	ATK+1 MP cost -1% Hate rise -1%	STR+1 Melee +1% Burn damage +1%	INT+1 Melee to Water +1% Cast time -1%	AGI+1 Melee to Wind +1% MaxHP+20	VIT+1 Melee to Earth +1% MaxHP+100	DEX+1 Heal reward +1% Heal recovery +1%	CRT+1 Bleed damage +1% Poison dmg +1%
Corona Weather Blauzen Range cut +1% Melee to Water +2%	ATK+1 MaxHP +1% MaxMP +1%	STR+1 Hate Rise +1% Melee+100	INT+1 Melee to Water +1% Water Magic +1%	AGI+1 Melee to Wind +1% MaxHP+100	VIT+1 Earth Magic +1% Melee +1%	DEX+1 Heal Received +1% Hate Rise -1%	CRT+1 EXP gain +1% Drop rate +1%
Leak Board Eisen MP Cost -8% Skill delay -0.3sec	ATK+1 Melee+100 MaxMP+20	STR+1 Melee to Fire +1% Hate Rise +1%	INT+1 Melee to Water +1% Water Magic +1%	AGI+1 Magic +1% Wind Magic +1%	VIT+1 EXP gain +1% Earth Magic +1%	DEX+1 Cast time -1% MP Cost -1%	CRT+1 Dark Magic +1% Drop rate +1%
Assassinate Griffith Critical damage +8% MeleeR•MagicR -2%	ATK+1 Hate Rise -1% Melee Pierce +1%	STR+1 Cast time -1% Melee +1%	INT+1 Melee to Water +1% Magic +1%	AGI+1 Wind Magic +1% Magic+100	VIT+1 EXP gain +1% Cook Success +1%	DEX+1 Poison dmg +1% Melee to Boss +1%	CRT+1 Melee+100 Bleed damage +1%
Sigduna Luchectus Heal Reward+10% MagicR+4%	ATK+1 MaxHP+1% MaxMP+1%	STR+1 Smith success +1% EXP gain +1%	INT+1 Melee to Water +1% MP Cost -1%	AGI+1 Tailoring success+1% Melee+100	VIT+1 Melee to Earth +1% Melee Pierce +1%	DEX+1 Heal Recovery +1% Magic+100	CRT+1 Poison dmg +1% Bleed damage +1%
Harp Gisable Deserlong Absolute Evasion +5% STR+3	ATK+1 MaxHP+1% MaxHP+100	STR+1 Melee+1% Burn damage +1%	INT+1 EXP gain +1% MP Cost -1%	AGI+1 Melee to Wind +1% Hate rise +1%	VIT+1 Melee to Earth +1% Melee+100	DEX+1 Heal Reward +1% Chasing success +1%	CRT+1 Poison dmg +1% Drop rate +1%
Fleur Prairie Zant MeleeR +2% VIT+2	ATK+1 Melee Pierce +1% Melee+1%	STR+1 Melee to Fire +1% Melee+100	INT+1 Drop rate +1% MP Cost -1%	AGI+1 Carpentry success+1% Hate rise +1%	VIT+1 Melee to Earth +1% Earth Magic +1%	DEX+1 MaxHP+100 Chasing success +1%	CRT+1 Melee to Dark +1% MaxMP+20
Gertella Cottonello MaxHP+7% Stun time-1sec	ATK+1 MaxHP+1% Hate rise+1%	STR+1 Hate rise+1% Melee+100	INT+1 Drop rate+1% Hate rise+1%	AGI+1 Alchemy Success+1% Hate rise+1%	VIT+1 Melee to Earth+1% Melee Pierce+1%	DEX+1 MaxMP+20 Heal Reward+1%	CRT+1 Melee to Dark+1% Dark Magic+1%
Dualmond Anubites Dark Magic+3% Fear time-2sec	ATK+1 MaxHP+1% Hate rise+1%	STR+1 EXP gain+1% Magic+1%	INT+1 Drop rate+1% MP Cost-1%	AGI+1 Magic+100 Cast time-1%	VIT+1 Alchemy Success+1% Melee Pierce+1%	DEX+1 MaxMP+20 Magic Pierce+1%	CRT+1 Melee to Dark+1% Dark Magic+1%
Memento Pain Hortes ATK+4% Item Delay-0.3sec	MATK+1 Melee+1% Magic+1%	STR+1 Melee to Earth+1% Fire Magic+1%	INT+1 Melee to Fire+1% Water Magic+1%	AGI+1 Melee to Water+1% Wind Magic+1%	VIT+1 Melee to Wind+1% Earth Magic+1%	DEX+1 Melee to Dark+1% Light Magic+1%	CRT+1 Melee to Light+1% Dark Magic+1%
Walion Rowalion Delay-0.2sec	EXP gain+1% Heal Recovery+1% Drop rate+1%	STR+1 ATK+1 Smith Success+1%	INT+1 MaxMP+20 Cook Success+1%	AGI+1 MATK+1 Tailoring Success+1%	VIT+1 MaxHP+100 Carpentry Success+1%	DEX+1 Cast time-1% Chasing Success+1%	CRT+1 Hate rise+1% Alchemy Success+1%
Rise Riot Eclaire Melee to Dark+2% DEX+3	ATK+1 MATK+1 EXP gain+1%	STR+1 Melee to Fire+1% Melee+100	INT+1 Melee to Water+1% Magic+100	AGI+1 Melee to Wind+1% Magic+1%	VIT+1 Melee to Earth+1% Melee+1%	DEX+1 Cast time-1% Drop rate+1%	CRT+1 Smith Success+1% Cook Success+1%

A fully unlocked Relic Glass has 49 squares, and production relics can be any size from 3 to 5 blocks. Making a 3-square is very rare - about a 5% chance - so aim for something reasonable, like fitting 11-13 in your Relic Glass.

{notes}


If you are using prod to max gears for profit or xp, soul crystas will probably definitely beat Melee to Element xtal, so keep this in mind.
While they are xtrade, they can be attached to tradeable gear, and traded like that.
If you can't make them yourself, buy them.

◇Carpenter's Soul (trade x, from Carpentry 235)
[Weapons] Production loss rate -3%

◇Cooker's Soul (trade x, from Cooking 235)
[Armor] Production loss rate -3%


It is also believed that the weapons from Tower of Delusion F11-20 (currently not released in EN) have Melee to Element+30%. This would make them the best weapon available for Chasing, and tied weapons for Smithing, Carpentry, and Alchemy. Unfortunately, they are Slot:1 xtrades, and could only be upgraded to 2s with a cash shop item.
But it's also possible that F21-30 or F31-40 or etc, could add an item to the Fragment shop that adds a 2nd slot to your equipped Tower of Delusion weapon.